LV Review-Journal Endorses Dean's Citizenship Verification Plan For Health Care Bill

Posted by: Staff in Immigration ReformHealth Care ReformFiscal Responsibility on Print 

The Las Vegas Review-Journal endorsed Congressman Heller's amendment to the Democrats' health care bill requiring the use to citizenship verification tools to determine eligibility for taxpayer-funded health care benefits:

President Obama's frenzied attempt to nationalize health care has hit a few snags, despite the best efforts of liberal congressional Democrats.

But it's worth noting at least one success the far left has scored when it comes to health care reform legislation: They made sure that taxpayers could be on the hook for covering the medical bills of illegal aliens.

That's right. Last week, the Democratic-controlled House Ways and Means Committee voted 26-15 -- on a straight party line -- to kill an amendment offered by Nevada Rep. Dean Heller that would have prevented illegals from receiving government subsidized health care under any reform proposal.

Democrats often trot out the 45 million uninsured in America as evidence that we need more public sector involvement in health care. Of course, a significant portion of those uninsured are illegal -- some estimates put it as high as 10 million.

Democrats have previously denied that they seek to cover illegals, saying they would not be eligible to participate in the public insurance option they hope to create. The question then becomes: What sort of mechanism do they propose to weed out the illegals?

In fact, they have proposed none. The Heller plan would have at least mandated that health organizations use federal data base checks to verify citizenship, but the Democrats have now put the kibosh on that approach.

Heller's plan would also have barred illegal aliens from qualifying for tax credits to subsidize the purchase of private health insurance coverage. But this, too, is apparently too much for Democrats to stomach in their effort to court the illegal vote.

Previous: Government Health Care Is Not The Answer

Trackback(0)
Comments (2)Add Comment
I can't find any record of this proposed amendment to the health care reform bill - can you help?
written by Kathy , July 31, 2009
Can someone please direct me to the actual text of this amendment that was proposed by Dean Heller regarding the prevention of health benefits by illegal immigrants? I have searched all through the bill text database for the 111th Congress (http://thomas.loc.gov/home/c111query.html), and I have reviewed all the legislation posted to Congressman Heller's website at http://heller.house.gov/legislation.shtml
I still can't find it!
(p.s. remove NOSPAM)
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
2nd District, Concerned Citizen
written by Les , August 13, 2009
Congressman Heller,

Thank you for your introduction of common sense to this health Insurance reform process. Know that there are plenty of us from the (formerly) Silent Majority, that are in utter awe of the hi-speed deterioration of our rights, and are firmly standing behind you.

Keep Up the Great Work!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0

Decrease input size | Increase input size

busy